The Rev. Gomer S. Rees - Pastor (6/1/26 - 4/16/41)
The Rev. Arthur Grammes - Supply Pastor
The Rev. Walter L. Williams - Pastor (12/7/41 - 12/27/49)
The Rev. Warren S. Harding - Pastor
The Rev. Dr. John D.M. Brown, - Supply Pastor
The Rev. Richard G. Hoffert - Pastor (8/3/50 - 3/7/56)
The Rev. Clarence A. Boyer - Interim Pastor
The Rev. Dr. Hugh E. Yost - Pastor (8/1/56 - 12/29/68)
The Rev. Kenneth F. Frickert - Minister of Education (7/17/60 - 9/15/63)
The Rev. William W.J. Ennis - Minister of Education (4/15/64 - 1967)
The Rev. Kenneth F. Frickert - Pastor (1969 - 1982)
The Rev. Carlton L. Heckman - Assistant/Visitation Pastor (1972 - 1979, 1983 - 1984)
The Rev. Richard G. Gardner - Intern (1970 - 1971)
The Rev. Eric C. Shafer - Pastor (1970 - 1971)
The Rev. Patricia Medley - Pastor (1971 - 1972)
The Rev. Charles "Rusty" May - Pastor (1972 - 1974)
Mary L. Pretz - (1974 -1975)
The Rev. William Gerber - Pastor (1974 - 1975)
Linda Masonheimer - Education/Youth (1975)
Sister Verna E. Meckes - Minister of Education/Parish Deaconess (9/1/76 - 1990)
The Rev. D. Michael Bennethum- Assistant Pastor (7/1/79 - 1983)
The Rev. Fred Blank - Interim Pastor (1983 - 1984)
The Rev. Dr. Ronald C. Yergey - Pastor (2/12/84 - 12/31/05)
The Rev. Dr. Paul A. Baglyos - Assistant/Associate Pastor (9/23/84 - 1988)
The Rev. Dr. Richard Klick - Visitation Pastor (1989 - 1991)
Linda Wasylik - Youth Fellowship Coordinator (1989 - 1990)
The Rev. Dr. Cynthia Long Lasher - Assistant/Associate Pastor (7/1/91 - 1996)
The Rev. Sherwood L. Dieter - Visitation Pastor (1996 - 1999)
The Rev. Kathleen Coleman - Seminarian (1994)
Susan D. Ruggles - Seminarian (1998 - 2000)
The Rev. John W. Tomlinson, Jr. - Visitation Pastor (1999 - 2011)
The Rev. Dr. Walter H. Wagner - Interim Pastor (2006)
The Rev. Donna T. Deal - Pastor (2007 - 2019)
Cynthia Simmons - Visitation (2010)
The Rev. Donald Schwartz - Visitation Pastor (2012 - 2020)
Brian Riedy - Vicar (8/2015 - 6/2016)
The Rev. Grace Olson - Transition Pastor (2019 - 2022)
The Rev. Cynthia Rader Geyer (2023 - present)